There is a
nagging unseemliness about photographing
suffering—the Vulture Effect—despite knowing your
purpose is not to exploit, but to help. By showing
suffering, by showing the compassionate action of
individuals who work selflessly to help alleviate
it, perhaps others will be moved to such action
themselves.
I’m here at the
Maryknoll hospice with Lok Yay, (‘revered
grandmother’ in Khmer), a 75-year old wisp of a
Buddhist nun who is well known around the AIDS wards
of Phnom Penh. Just the sight of her brings a
glimmer of life to the man’s eyes, and soon he is
basking in her soothing words, her healing hands,
and her simple, loving presence.
Beth Goldring, an American
Buddhist nun and founding director of Brahmavihara,
began her AIDS project chaplainry in the years
before the arrival of ARV’s, at the height of the
crisis. Unique in Cambodia, Beth and her Khmer
staff, very much like Mother Theresa in India, came
into being solely to offer love, comfort, compassion
and spiritual sustenance to the dying. As ARV’s
began to become available and more people started
surviving, Brahmavihara’s purview expanded to
include a host of necessarily elastic social
services and facilitations for AIDS patients and
their families.
There is a magic about Beth
and her team unlike anything I have ever witnessed. When she
walks into a suffering AIDS ward it transforms into a roomful of smiles and hugs. When
she performs healing techniques on a patient, it is
extraordinary to see the suffering fade, replaced by
a deep peacefulness.
Lok Yay has a different
style and uses different techniques, but she too
carries the magic. Beth recounts occasions where Lok
Yay has brought patients with insurvivable CD4
counts (immunity levels as low as 1 on a scale of
1500) back from the edge, and eventually back to
levels strong enough to take ARV’s and survive.
About 330,000-440,000
Cambodians, some 3-4% of the population, are
infected with the HIV virus, the highest
rate in South East Asia. Before the arrival of
significant amounts of ARV’s only a
few years ago, some 40,000 people a year were
succumbing to the disease. Thanks to ARV’s and still
less than adequate AIDS awareness programs, that
number has been reduced to 10-12,000. AIDS orphans
number in the hundreds of thousands.
The great tragedy of
Cambodia has been long and well documented, but
sadly, is far from over. Genocides and the physical
and psychological scars they leave behind take
generations to overcome. Nearly 30 years after the
end of Pol Pot’s murderous reign, even though a good
measure of stability has returned, life is still
cheap for too many.
Too many doctors make a
practice of extorting money from AIDS patients,
leaving them to die if they cannot pay. Too many
corrupt government officials make a practice of
skimming relief money earmarked for AIDS victims,
even going so far as to force long disbursement
delays in
order to cover their crimes in red tape. One is
incredulous at how they can rationalize their
actions, actions that leave people suffering and
dying just so they can pad their bank accounts.
Perhaps they point to what happens all too often on
the streets. Some patients will gamble away their
ARV’s. Some will sell them on the black market. Some
HIV-positive sex workers will knowingly have sex
without condoms.
But why? “Why” is what is
willfully ignored by corrupt officials. A person
gambles their ARV’s, their very lives, because they
live in ignorance and desperation. A mother sells
her ARV’s on the black market because she is
desperate to feed her children. A low-end sex worker
sells her diseased body for 1,500 riel (about 38
cents) because she is desperate to feed herself, or
for a cheap high to dull the pain. The corrupt officials
are apparently too busy looking down their noses at
such acts of desperation to consider the fact that
it is their own greed and blind cruelty that is a
major contributor.
More than two months
have passed, and just as I’m getting some idea of
what I’m doing, my work here is nearing its natural
conclusion. Surviving patients receive copies of
their photographs, still something of a rarity
amongst Cambodia’s poor. They are as fascinated with
their images—even in such dire straits—as I am with
their warmth and courage in the face of it. The
gratitude they express both surprises and humbles
me. I try with words to express my own warmth
towards them, my own gratitude, but it feels
woefully inadequate. But I have learned here that
cultural divides are most easily crossed, complex
feelings more meaningfully expressed, with something
as simple as a heartfelt gaze.
It’s my last day, and in
an unplanned bookend, I find myself again with Lok
Yay standing in the same room in the same Maryknoll
hospice with the same man from the first day. I
should be surprised to see him still alive, but
somehow I’m not. The eyes are still sunken from his
long illness, but they know longer speak of
death. One cannot help but think that this wisp of a
nun with the healing hands and the loving presence
might have had a little something to do with it.
—Bennett Stevens